For instance, the fact that I had a theme song (and a soundtrack, though I never really got that far) seemed to weird some folks out and amuse the rest. It kind of bummed me out,
I don't care what they say, it was the awesomest theme song ever.
On the plus side, I did get to indulge the part of me that likes making authentic looking game handouts:
So, of course, I want to try it again, with a different group of players, who I think/hope might catch the vibe a bit better. I guess I ought to pitch it to a couple of them and see if I get any bites.